Someone is standing on stage behind a microphone with an envelope in his/her hand. He or she states, "...the award goes to..." tears the envelope open, allows space for a pregnant pause to create suspense (this is after all supposed to be a surprise), then continues...
*POW! Surprise!
The name that he or she just mentioned really is a surprise to you. You feel like someone crept up stealthily behind you and flicked the back of your ear with a finger. Not particularly painful, but extremely annoying and you were absolutely not prepared for that. Then you wonder, "why was I surprised anyway?"
Well, you were probably surprised because you probably thought they will actually give the award to someone who actually deserves it. Then you probably feel rather silly because you are probably thinking someone can see the surprise all over your face and that person is probably laughing. Hehehehe, all these probabilities.
In truth, our concern really is the probability. We are aware of facts, and we know that when we line up all these facts (which is essentially what a survey or a vote is supposed to do - record facts), the likelihood that one of the nominees will stand out is higher than others. In some cases, it might not always be that obvious, but when we hear the winner, we know that the facts could never possibly have pointed us in that direction. At least it should be someone else, right? RIGHT? How should I know?
It doesn't often happen in developed countries, because they know the backlash from the discerning people (or at least the media) will cost them dearly - particularly in the future. And even when it does, you can expect some drama a la Kanye West (...ï'mma let you finish, but...). But not everyone is brazen (or possibly off it) like Mr. West. We can't all (or always) storm the stage and register our protests. So what's left for us to do in developing countries? When the announcement is passed, I feel as though it should sound like this:
...the award goes to...
- The Organisers' close friend, who really could do with a favour
- The highest bidder - after all, they paid us to make sure they'll win
- One of the few who was dumb enough to send in a nomination for this category
Then someone who represents some sort of auditors comes to announce and confirm that the votes have been correctly counted and there was no room for any tricks. That, at least, we can believe. After all, the auditing firm has no involvement with the "select panel" right?
I remember a few years ago. I complained about the banking awards and how I didn't believe a certain bank should hold a certain award. My colleague explained the selection criteria, which interestingly did not involve a "select panel" but rather customers of the banking industry. I wondered why they had never selected an eminent person such as myself to respond, as it will give me a chance to vent my frustrations about the banks in the country. Yes, he also laughed like you are probably doing now, but it wasn't that funny for me because I was analysing the statistics behind it. How could they sample the banking population of Ghana (supposedly under 2 million persons nationwide), such that I had:
- never been selected to fill a questionnaire
- never even SEEN a questionnaire
- not met a single person (or company) who had seen a questionnaire before - for the avoidance of doubt, this includes people who actually WORK in banks!
Ok, so you are probably thinking I am overstating how important I am and how many people I know. But these are questions for you to ask yourself also, and I will be glad for your feedback in the comments below.
But lets move from the banking awards, because it is just one example of the numerous "Award" events that take place around the world almost every single week. Let's move to where you are likely thinking about, "what prompted this posting?"
I know it is belated, but this posting was prompted by the current winner of the "Marketing Woman of the Year" award and of course, many other winners of the Chartered Institute of Marketing Awards. Kudos to all the winners, and of course to the esteemed "select panel." How is it that the Managing Director of the GHANA AIRPORTS COMPANY Ltd wins MARKETING woman of the year??????? What has she been marketing? I ask this question in all seriousness, because it baffles me. I write with no malice or offense intended to the lady.
Surely it cannot be our one and only international airport that she has been marketing? The very same facility, which, during the period under review, has suffered from a leaking roof, collapsed ceiling, regular power outages, failing baggage belts and general incompetency on the part of its staff? Or has it been due to the "gateway to Africa" concept? She is not the originator of that idea, and she hasn't put in place any real measures to ensure that Accra is a gateway. There are new international airlines operating to and from Ghana, but very little in terms of increased domestic (both in the country and on the continent) activity. I just don't get it. Its like going to eat at some restaurant - you already know there's not enough salt or pepper in the soup, but you eat it anyway; then one day you find the meat you're eating is actually roadkill, and yet the manager looks you in the face and says "I don't know what you're talking about, but we are the best around, and we want you to be happy. Please come again"
I also don't get how Toyota gets into the "Hall of fame" although they couldn't win Motor Firm of the year (which they always win). Was that a way of taking them out of the running so that the second best could scoop it? Will this happen next year? It will be useful to understand the criteria and selection process. But will that really help or will it just give us reasons to poke more holes into the story?
And then there's those who flaunt their awards - shamelessly lobbying their friends, clients and suppliers to design and pay for an advert to congratulate them. It's one thing showing off your dubious award, but seriously, having to prompt someone to congratulate you? Whats the matter with you? Don't you have real friends?
So on and on it goes. Less and less we believe in the awards, but we still look on curiously every year; hoping that we just may find something that we are impressed with. Its like looking with fascination at a dead body and wondering if the person will suddenly rise up; knowing that you will run away if he/she does get up, but still standing there anyway.
So, until I get to sit on some "select panel" or I am selected to receive some sort of monetary award, I won't believe the hype.
Until next post...